New York Judge Fines Lawyers Who Used ChatGPT To Create Legal Brief

The lawyers who submitted a legal brief that was created using OpenAI’s large language model (LLM) ChatGPT were sanctioned by a Manhattan judge on Thursday.

Judge P. Kevin Castel imposed a $5,000 fine on attorneys Peter LoDuca and Steven Schwartz, and their law firm Levidow, Levidow & Oberman. Castel said that the two “abandoned their responsibilities” when they used artificial intelligence to produce a legal brief that came with made-up cases and citations for what was supposed to be an unremarkable lawsuit in March.

Their client, Roberto Mata, was suing the airline Avianca over claims that he was wounded when a metal service cart hit his knee on an August 2019 flight from El Salvador to New York. Avianca then filed a motion to dismiss the case, prompting the lawyers to “write” the 10-page legal brief.

The judge said that Mata’s lawyers, which he addressed as “Respondents,” “continued to stand by the fake opinions after judicial orders called their existence into question.” 

“But if the matter had ended with Respondents coming clean about their actions shortly after they received the defendant’s March 15 brief questioning the existence of the cases, or after they reviewed the Court’s Orders of April 11 and 12 requiring production of the cases, the record now would look quite different,” Castel wrote.

The judge also ordered LoDuca and Schwartz to notify their client and each of the judges whose names were “wrongfully invoked” in the made-up cases and citations about the sanctions. He noted the potential harm that being falsely invoked as authors of bogus opinions can cause to the reputation of the judges.

Castel added that the court will not order the respondents to apologize, “because a compelled apology is not a sincere apology.” Instead, he leaves the decision to the ChatGPT lawyers. He also emphasized that the fine is not imposed as a means to punish or compensate, but instead to “advance the interests of deterrence.”

“Technological advances are commonplace and there is nothing inherently improper about using a reliable artificial intelligence tool for assistance,” he wrote. “But existing rules impose a gatekeeping role on attorneys to ensure the accuracy of their filings.”

In a separate order, Castel granted Avianca’s request to dismiss the suit on the grounds that it was filed after the two-year window allowed for international air travel claims under the Montreal Convention has expired.


Information for this story was found via CNBC, The New York Times, and the sources and companies mentioned. The author has no securities or affiliations related to the organizations discussed. Not a recommendation to buy or sell. Always do additional research and consult a professional before purchasing a security. The author holds no licenses.

Video Articles

Silver’s Finally Breaking the System | Keith Neumeyer – First Majestic

The Best News for Gold Was the Drop! – Peter Grandich

McEwen Copper: The Los Azules Feasibility Study

Recommended

Steadright To Conduct Multi-Phased Exploration At Historic Goundafa Polymetallic Mine

Goliath Resources Drills 10.72 g/t Gold Over 7.83 Metres At Surebet

Related News

OpenAI Board Found Out About the Launch of ChatGPT on Twitter

Former OpenAI board member Helen Toner revealed that the board was not informed about the...

Friday, May 31, 2024, 08:03:44 AM

xAI Seeks Emergency Order to Block Ex-Employee From Starting at OpenAI

Elon Musk’s xAI has filed a federal lawsuit against a former engineer, alleging he stole...

Tuesday, September 2, 2025, 03:41:00 PM

Microsoft Made Preparations to Absorb OpenAI’s Departing Staff — Except They Didn’t Leave

Microsoft (Nasdaq: MSFT) was getting ready to receive OpenAI employees who wanted to follow CEO...

Monday, November 27, 2023, 07:37:22 AM

New York Times v. Microsoft, OpenAI: The Biggest Argument to Copyright Issues of Generative AI

The New York Times has filed a federal lawsuit against OpenAI and Microsoft, accusing them...

Thursday, December 28, 2023, 11:19:00 AM

Bard Overboard: Why Microsoft Bing Finally Has A Chance In The Search Engine Race

The sudden ubiquity of AI-powered search has launched a tight race between the world’s tech...

Thursday, February 9, 2023, 09:14:00 AM