Red Lobster’s Bankruptcy Filing Reveals Mismanagement and Financial Struggles

Red Lobster, the iconic seafood restaurant chain, has filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy. The details emerging from the filing are startling, revealing significant mismanagement and financial difficulties that have plagued the company.

The restaurant chain is currently burdened with $1 billion in debt, while holding only $30 million in cash. A major factor contributing to Red Lobster’s financial woes is a deal made by its previous private equity owner, who sold the land on which Red Lobster restaurants are located and then leased it back to the company at above-market rates.

One of the most controversial aspects of Red Lobster’s recent operations involves the $20 Endless Shrimp promotion. While this deal attracted customers, it ended up costing the company $11 million.

Complicating matters further, one of Red Lobster’s owners, Thai Union—a major seafood firm that also owns Chicken of the Sea—may have used the promotion to dump its shrimp supply through the chain’s 578 North American restaurants. Thai Union became Red Lobster’s sole shrimp supplier, allegedly overcharging for shrimp and bypassing quality reviews. The company has since written off its over $500 million investment in Red Lobster.

Since 2019, Red Lobster’s sales have plummeted by 30%, a decline that has only been exacerbated by the pandemic and changing consumer preferences.

In light of these quality concerns, some have suggested that Red Lobster needed a figure like Yukitaka Yamaguchi, Japan’s Tuna King, known for his rigorous quality control and ability to identify the origin of fish with a single bite.

Interestingly, Red Lobster experienced a brief sales surge in 2016 after being mentioned by Beyoncé in her song “Formation.” Despite this fleeting boost, the company’s long-term issues remained unaddressed.

Speculation meanwhile has already begun on a new potential acquirer for Red Lobster. Rumors suggest a hedge fund may be considering a $1 billion acquisition, with plans to integrate the restaurants into a cruise line and eventually sell the company for a significant profit.

Michael McDonald, a known analyst, highlighted the role of hedge funds in Red Lobster’s current predicament, pointing out how the fund sold off the restaurant lands and leased them back at inflated rates.

The instability at the top has also allegedly contributed to Red Lobster’s downfall. The company has seen five different CEOs in the last five years, leading to a lack of consistent leadership and strategic direction.

Jonathan Tibus, the current CEO of Red Lobster, provided a detailed declaration in support of the company’s Chapter 11 petitions. He outlined the company’s financial distress and the strategic steps being taken to stabilize operations and maximize value for stakeholders.

Financial and Operational Challenges

Red Lobster’s performance has been deteriorating for several years, according to Tibus. The annual guest count has declined by approximately 30% since 2019, with only marginal improvements from pandemic levels. Although net sales increased by 25% from 2021 to 2023, the last twelve months have shown a material decline.

The company’s consolidated adjusted EBITDA fell by more than 60%, resulting in a $76 million net loss in fiscal year 2023. This has significantly decreased Red Lobster’s cash position from $100 million in May 2023 to less than $30 million by the end of the year.

He further explained that Red Lobster has been severely impacted by macroeconomic factors, particularly inflation. Rising restaurant prices, driven by labor and commodity inflation, have outpaced grocery prices, deterring consumers from dining out. Additionally, 50% of states have increased minimum hourly wages in 2024, further squeezing the company’s margins.

A significant portion of Red Lobster’s leases are priced above market rates, with $64 million spent on underperforming stores in 2023 alone, placing additional strain on the company’s liquidity.

Former CEO Paul Kenny’s decision to make the Ultimate Endless Shrimp promotion a permanent $20 menu item was a costly mistake, said Tibus. This decision, along with excessive in-store promotion, led to supply shortages and financial burdens, particularly with its equity sponsor, Thai Union.

“The Debtors are exploring the impact of the control Thai Union exerted, in concert with Mr. Kenny and other Thai Union-affiliated entities and individuals, and whether actions taken in light of these parties’ varying interests were appropriate and consistent with applicable duties and obligations to Red Lobster,” Tibus wrote.

In December 2023, efforts were made to restructure Red Lobster out of court, but these attempts were unsuccessful. Following the appointment of restructuring expert Lawrence Hirsh, negotiations with lenders aimed at creating a new equity structure failed. CEO Horace Dawson’s retirement and the appointment of Jonathan Tibus marked the beginning of more aggressive restructuring efforts.

In February 2024, Tibus said he developed a three-prong strategic plan to improve operations. This included making Red Lobster a great place to work, providing consistent customer experiences, and reducing costs by closing non-performing stores and eliminating nonproductive spending. These efforts were accompanied by a marketing and sale process led by Hilco Corporate Finance.

Recognizing the need for Chapter 11 proceedings, Red Lobster secured debtor-in-possession financing and entered into a stalking horse asset purchase agreement with RL Purchaser LLC. This agreement, supported by the Prepetition Term Loan Lenders, outlines a timeline to minimize the impact on operations and maximize value through a structured sale process.

Information for this story was found via the sources and companies mentioned. The author has no securities or affiliations related to the organizations discussed. Not a recommendation to buy or sell. Always do additional research and consult a professional before purchasing a security. The author holds no licenses.

Leave a Reply