Friday, November 14, 2025

Critics Tear Into Carney’s Major Projects Showcase

  • Carney’s latest major projects announcement ties a glossy fast track narrative to a heavily leveraged 2025 budget that critics say masks both reannouncements and rising credit risk.

The federal government’s newest slate of “major projects” is being sold as a transformative fast track for nation building but is landing in a 2025 budget context that shows a record $78 billion new hole in Canada’s public finances.

Finance Canada says the Major Projects Office will “fast-track major nation-building projects that are in the national interest” and will “connect our country, attract domestic and global capital, and create high-paying careers,” tying the program directly to capital attraction and employment objectives.

The latest official list includes seven projects spanning conservation, transmission, liquefied natural gas, critical minerals, graphite and hydro power, including the Northwest Critical Conservation Corridor, North Coast Transmission Line, Ksi Lisims LNG, Canada Nickel’s Crawford Nickel Project, Nouveau Monde Graphite’s Matawinie Mine, Northcliff Resources’ Sisson Mine and the Iqaluit Nukkiksautiit Hydro Project, a portfolio that notably still contains no conventional oil pipeline.

The federal Sankey chart for the 2025 to 2026 fiscal year shows total revenues of $584 billion comprised of $407 billion in personal income tax, $84 billion in corporate income tax, $51 billion in GST and $42 billion in other revenues, implying a system still heavily reliant on wage earners for more than two thirds of Ottawa’s tax take.

On the spending side, the same chart presents a matching $584 billion outflow with $284 billion in direct program expenses, $114 billion in major transfers to persons, $105 billion in transfers to other governments and $50 billion in public debt charges.

Former Alberta economic adviser David Knight Legg calls Canada’s major projects announcements “a national embarrassment” and “an economic ‘hostage release’ program,” arguing they highlight “how uninvestible Canada has become under the Liberal party.” He says the same budget that underpins the Major Projects Office “just punched a record new $78 billion hole through our public finances” and comes on top of roughly $1 trillion in borrowing “to fund their failed decade of central planning, green slush funds and EV mandates while real infrastructure projects wait years for the Liberal party to bless them.”

A separate line graph sourced from OECD data via IceCap Asset Management shows the combined federal and provincial tax take hovering near 27% of GDP in recent years, with the federal share peaking around 15% in 2010 before sliding toward roughly 12% while provincial receipts rise from about 13% to around 15%.

Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre is also attacking the projects list from a different angle, accusing Prime Minister Mark Carney of rebranding previously planned private or provincial builds as new federal victories. He says Carney is “standing up, doing photo ops, announcing that he’s going to approve a bunch of projects that were already going to happen,” citing Ksi Lisims as a case where a Liberal minister allegedly promised back in 2017 that the project would be underway within a year and calling today’s move a reannouncement of “that same liberal promise.”

That critique is reinforced on the timing side by MP Dan Albas, who notes that the BC Hydro North Coast Transmission Line project began planning in 2022 and “is already scheduled to begin construction in the summer of 2026 regardless of any federal election,” adding that “this construction timeline was set before PM Carney even concocted the idea of the MPO,” which raises questions about how many of the announced projects are genuinely accelerated.

Energy analyst Heather Exner-Pirot says that on closer inspection “we thought we were getting regulatory streamlining but what we’re getting is government financing,” suggesting that the initiative may be layering new federal capital commitments and risk guarantees on top of existing multi year regulatory processes rather than materially shortening them.

Yet the program has defenders who stress the importance of political stability and continuity for investors and workers now pinned to the new project slate. Commentator Bruce Anderson writes that “with the latest round of announced major projects to be fast-tracked many businesses and workers will be counting on the BQ, CPC and NDP to not force an election and put these projects in doubt,” implying that cancellation risk tied to an early election could weigh on hiring and capital deployment even before shovels hit the ground.

Knight Legg concludes that “2026 is the end of the Liberal lost decade” and predicts “first recession. Then debt downgrade. Then an election,” warning that Carney can “go back offshore to his assets and all the other global investors who like him don’t invest in Canada under Liberal mismanagement.”


Information for this briefing was found via the sources and the companies mentioned. The author has no securities or affiliations related to this organization. Not a recommendation to buy or sell. Always do additional research and consult a professional before purchasing a security. The author holds no licenses.

Leave a Reply

Video Articles

Gold Isn’t In A Bubble, Currency Is. – Doug Casey

The Real Move Begins When They Cut Rates | Peter Krauth

Is Altamira Gold Sitting On Brazil’s Next Big Gold Discovery?

Recommended

Stifel Initiates Coverage On Goliath Resources With $5.00 Price Target

ESGold Completes Mill Building Construction, Final Equipment Procurement Underway

Related News

Carney to Announce Second Round of Fast-Track Infrastructure Projects

Prime Minister Mark Carney will unveil the second round of Canada’s fast-track infrastructure initiative on...

Wednesday, November 12, 2025, 10:19:00 AM

Major Projects Office’s “Second Wave” Get Business Development Teams

Ottawa seems to have begun deploying “business development teams” to up-and-coming files, with at least...

Monday, September 15, 2025, 10:47:00 AM

Former Trans Mountain CEO Tapped to Lead Canada’s Major Projects Office

Prime Minister Mark Carney on Friday appointed Dawn Farrell, the former CEO of Trans Mountain...

Monday, September 1, 2025, 09:02:01 AM

Zero Pipelines On Ottawa’s National Interest Projects List

Ottawa’s first “projects of national interest” list contains zero oil pipelines, according to three sources...

Thursday, September 11, 2025, 10:36:00 AM

Carney Picks Five For Major Projects, No Pipelines

Prime Minister Mark Carney referred only five projects to the new Major Projects Office for...

Friday, September 12, 2025, 07:15:00 AM