The company Ottawa backed to preserve a fourth national wireless competitor is invoking lower cellphone bills to defend a proposed takeover of one of the incumbents it was meant to challenge.
Quebecor said on Thursday that Freedom Mobile plans in BC were advertised at prices up to 44% below comparable offerings from Bell and TELUS. It also criticized Bell’s $40 device charges as it pursues an unsolicited $31 billion acquisition of TELUS.
The statement followed BCE, Bell’s parent, holding preliminary talks with TELUS. The discussions were attributed to unnamed sources by The Globe and Mail.
“A combination between Bell and TELUS would not represent a positive outcome for consumers,” Quebecor said.
It accused Bell of raising monthly mobile rates by as much as $6 and charging unwanted fees of up to $40, while criticizing similar practices at TELUS.
The $40 issue has a regulatory basis, although the legal question remains unresolved. In June, the CRTC opened a proceeding examining whether Bell’s device-handling charge, TELUS’s SIM-card fee, and charges introduced by Rogers conflict with restrictions on fees that hinder switching providers.
In 2023, federal approval of the transfer of Freedom Mobile to Quebecor’s Videotron helped preserve a fourth major wireless group following Rogers’ acquisition of Shaw. Videotron committed to offering specified plans at least 20% below February 2023 incumbent benchmarks, backed by potential damages of up to $200 million. Freedom’s transferred spectrum licences also carry a restriction on transfers until March 2033, subject to exceptions.
Acquiring TELUS would combine Quebecor’s Freedom and Videotron operations with an incumbent, leaving Bell and Rogers as the other two large national wireless groups. Quebecor argues the enlarged company would have the resources to invest and compete, estimating $160 million in annual operating savings and $235 million in capital efficiencies.
Under the recent proposal, TELUS investors would receive $6.35 cash and 0.17 Quebecor Class B shares per share. Quebecor’s initial $19.45 implied valuation depended on its November 13 share price.
TELUS’s board has warned that Quebecor has not explained how it would secure regulatory approval. Industry Minister Mélanie Joly said competition authorities would independently and rigorously review any transaction, without prejudging the outcome.
Quebecor and TELUS are scheduled to meet November 23. The central regulatory issue is whether claimed consumer savings justify removing the fourth major competitor Ottawa worked to establish.