Supreme Court Sides With Métis Over Saskatchewan On Land Claims
The Supreme Court has handed down a landmark ruling in a unanimous decision regarding a dispute between the Métis Nation-Saskatchewan (MN-S) and the Saskatchewan government, ruling that MN-S can seek a judicial review of the permitting process for a uranium project near Patterson Lake.
The project in question involves Vancouver-based NexGen Energy, which applied for field mineral exploration permits in March 2021. NexGen’s initial exploration permits were granted in July 2021, after the company and the province discussed the project’s implications for Métis rights in the region.
The MN-S, believing that Saskatchewan’s Ministry of Environment had not adequately consulted them, sought a judicial review. That review was challenged by the province on the grounds that it duplicated a larger, separate case about consultation on asserted Métis land claims.
However, Justice Malcolm Rowe wrote that even if there are parallel legal matters covering similar ground, it does not automatically amount to an abuse of process. As Rowe stated, Indigenous litigants can be at fault for such abuse, yet courts must remember that “court procedures should facilitate, not impede, the just resolution of Aboriginal claims.”
The Supreme Court essentially disagreed with the province, and the judicial review will now move forward.
MN-S President Glen McCallum expressed hope that the ruling will lead to more productive conversations with the province, saying he wants to “work out our differences” and find a “common understanding.”
For Saskatchewan, the decision reinforces a policy obligation to engage with Indigenous communities before approving resource projects, even when commercial rights remain unproven. A spokesperson for the Ministry of Justice and Attorney General acknowledged the outcome, noting that while the Supreme Court dismissed the province’s appeal, it recognized concerns about having to argue “the same case twice.”
Premier Scott Moe commented that although Saskatchewan has made strides in its relationships with Indigenous communities, “there’s always more work to do.”
NexGen Energy entered into a historic Metis Impact Benefit Agreement with MN-S in 2023, which at the time was said to be the single largest agreement of its nature in the country. The arrangement is expected to provide northern communities with economic stability over the course of generastions.
Information for this briefing was found via CBC and the sources mentioned. The author has no securities or affiliations related to this organization. Not a recommendation to buy or sell. Always do additional research and consult a professional before purchasing a security. The author holds no licenses.
