A lawyer for one of the men on trial in the 2022 kidnapping of Aiden Pleterski called the abduction a “farce” in court Thursday and suggested he filmed himself as a captive to win investor sympathy. Pleterski denied it.
Leora Shemesh, who represents Alfredo Paladino, suggested during cross-examination in Ontario Superior Court that Pleterski produced the video himself so it would go viral and reach investors pursuing bankruptcy claims against him. The footage, shown to the jury, shows Pleterski with visible injuries apologizing and describing where their money went.
Pleterski testified his captors recorded it in a basement and told him to take all the blame. He said parts of what he said were true, parts were false and said under duress, and parts he said on his own.
Some investors pushed Pleterski, of Whitby, into bankruptcy in the summer of 2022. A bankruptcy trustee’s report found he had taken in more than $40 million from investors. That December, according to court documents, he was abducted in downtown Toronto and taken on a roughly three-day drive across southern Ontario.
In July 2023, police arrested Akil Heywood, an investor who, with his non-profit foundation, had put $740,000 into Pleterski’s business, and charged him with kidnapping. Five men in all were charged in the abduction. Heywood has maintained his innocence and is now one of three men on trial. A video of a bruised Pleterski apologizing to investors, the one at the center of Thursday’s testimony, surfaced the same month.
Paladino, Heywood and Rakeem Henry have pleaded not guilty to kidnapping and extorting Pleterski over three days in early December 2022. The Crown alleges Heywood was the “driving force” of the plot, and that Paladino and Henry executed it.
Hussein Aly, Heywood’s lawyer, wrapped up two days of questioning Pleterski on Thursday afternoon, repeatedly accusing him of lying about his investment business and his testimony. Aly suggested Pleterski invented Heywood’s role out of anger at being forced into bankruptcy by Heywood and another investor. Pleterski said Heywood invested with him and later threatened him over repayment.
Aly put it to Pleterski that bank records show $4.8 million in spending from November 2020 to August 2022, including about $1.1 million on travel and $1 million on entertainment, and that he never traded at all. Pleterski said he did trade and blamed the crypto market crash of late 2021 and 2022 for his investors’ losses.
Pleterski, who turned 28 on Wednesday, testified he was beaten and tortured and believed he would die. He was convicted October 29 of defrauding investors, and the Crown dropped a money laundering charge. He has not been sentenced.
Previously: ‘Crypto King’ Aiden Pleterski Arrested on Fraud Charges in Ontario
The Crown says Deren Akyeam-Pong led the abduction. He has pleaded guilty to nine charges.
Pleterski is due back on the stand Friday afternoon.